If your brand sells through retailers, the pages that decide your sales belong to somebody else, and most brands have never looked at them in any organised way. You can learn a great deal in a single afternoon with a spreadsheet and a browser, looking only at what any shopper can see. This guide gives you the method we would use by hand, and it also sets out where an afternoon stops being enough.
What You Need
Five retailers
Your three largest by sales and two that you suspect are underperforming.
Ten products
Current bestsellers and anything in a live promotion, with the agreed price and content for each to hand.
A private browser window
Signed out, so that you see what a new shopper sees, and a phone for a second look.
Check Every Product Page
Open each of the ten products on each of the five retailers, which gives you fifty pages, and record the same six things for every one of them.
| Check | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Price | Does it match what was agreed, including any promotion that should be running today? |
| Images | Are they current, complete and in the right order, or left over from an earlier season? |
| Title and copy | Is the product named correctly, and does the description say what yours does? |
| Availability | Are the sizes, colours or variants that sell best showing as in stock? |
| Reviews | Is the rating visible, and do recent reviews point to a fault on the page itself? |
| Presence | If the product cannot be found at all, record that as the most serious finding of the day |
Search the Way a Shopper Would
On each retailer's site, search for your brand name and then for your three most important product types without the brand name, such as "running shoes" or "waterproof jacket". Write down where your first product appears for each search and which competitors sit above it. The unbranded searches matter most, because they show what a shopper sees before deciding whose product to buy. Shoppers are also beginning to ask AI assistants what to buy, which we cover in our article on AI in retail.
Look at the Category Pages and the Home Page
Open the main category your products belong to and count how many of the first twenty products are yours, then note who holds the banners and the featured positions. Do the same on the home page. If you are paying for placement, or were promised it, this is where you find out whether you are getting it.
Keep the Evidence
Take a screenshot of anything that is wrong, with the date and the page address visible, and file it against the row in your spreadsheet. A dated picture of the page is what turns a complaint into a request a retailer can act on, and it lets you prove later that a fix was made.
Rank What You Found
| Finding | How urgent | Who to send it to |
|---|---|---|
| A promotion not running, or running at the wrong price | Today, because the campaign is already under way | Your account contact at the retailer, with the screenshot |
| A product missing or showing as unavailable | Today | The account contact and your own supply team |
| Wrong images, titles or copy | Soon, ahead of the next promotion | The retailer's content or e-commerce team |
| Poor position in search or in the category | At the next trade review | The buyer, with the comparison against competitors |
What an Afternoon Cannot Show You
An afternoon covers one day, five retailers and ten products. Pages change daily, most brands sell through far more than five retailers, and the faults that cost the most are often the ones that appear for a weekend and have gone by Monday. Use the afternoon to find out how large the problem is, and if the answer worries you, that is the point at which checking by hand should give way to checking by software.
Common Questions
No. Everything in this guide uses the public pages that any shopper can open, so there is nothing to request and nothing to sign in to.
By hand, as often as you can manage, and always before and during a promotion. Start each time with the retailers and products that failed the time before.
That is what the dated screenshots are for. Send the picture of the page beside the agreed terms, ask for a date by which it will be corrected, and check again on that date.
BY BANKS runs this kind of audit every day across more than 200 retailers as part of our digital retail intelligence service, with analysts who raise each finding with the retailer and confirm the fix. If your afternoon turns up more than you expected, get in touch and we will show you what a full audit of your retailers would cover.
Ready to Build Something?
If this resonated, let's talk about how we can apply these ideas to your business.
Start a Conversation