Most of the businesses I meet never chose to run on ten subscriptions. They chose one because it solved the problem in front of them, then another for the next problem, and a few years later the whole operation was running on a stack that nobody designed. I build bespoke platforms for a living, so you might expect me to say the answer is to replace the lot. It rarely is, and I regularly tell clients to keep tools they arrived ready to throw away. This is how I work out which is which.

Start With the Work

The first question I ask has nothing to do with features. I ask what the business does differently from its competitors, because that is where software either helps you or holds you back. Accounting, payroll and email work the same way in every company, which is why off-the-shelf tools handle them so well and why I would never rebuild them. The way you quote a job, schedule a crew, allocate stock or approve a purchase is usually yours alone, and that is the work a subscription pushes into somebody else's shape.

The Four Things I Look At

What I look atKeep the subscription whenBuild your own when
How standard the job isEvery business does it the same wayIt is how you win customers or keep them
How often data is retypedThe tool holds its own data and nobody copies it outThe same order, customer or job is entered in two or more places
What growth does to the billThe price stays sensible as you add peopleEvery new starter means another seat in several tools
Who can change itYou are content to wait for the vendor's next releaseYou need it to change when the business does

Of the four, the second tells me the most. When I spend time inside an operation I watch for the moments where a person is acting as the connection between two systems, reading a figure from one screen and typing it into another, or exporting a spreadsheet every Friday so that a different team can import it on Monday. Those people are doing integration work by hand, and they are usually among the most capable in the building, which makes it an expensive way to move data around.

When Ten Subscriptions Is the Right Answer

A young business that changes shape every quarter should stay on subscriptions, because they cost little to start and little to leave. Having funded products of my own, I would not spend that money on a platform before the business had settled into a shape worth building around. The same goes for any team whose tools are doing a standard job well and whose people are not copying data between them. If nothing is being typed twice and the monthly bill still makes sense, there is no case for change, and I will say so.

When One Platform Wins

The case for a platform of your own builds slowly, and it tends to show itself in the same few ways:

  • The monthly numbers are assembled by hand from three or four exports, and nobody fully trusts them because the systems disagree.
  • A new member of staff needs half a dozen logins before they can do the job.
  • There is a step in the process that exists only because two tools cannot talk to each other.
  • You have changed the way you work to suit a product, and you can name what it cost you.

When I hear two or three of those in a first conversation, the business has usually outgrown what it bought, and the subscriptions have become the thing it works around.

Buy what is common, build what is yours

Keep the subscriptions that do a standard job well, build the part of the operation that is particular to you, and connect the two so that nothing is typed twice. Almost every platform we build ends up following that rule.

It Is Rarely All or Nothing

The headline makes it sound like a choice between two extremes, and in practice it almost never is. A platform usually starts with one area of the business, the one where the retyping and the workarounds hurt most, and it sits alongside the tools worth keeping. Your accounting package stays, your payment provider stays, and the platform exchanges data with both so that an invoice raised in one appears in the other without anyone touching it. Other areas join when there is a reason for them to, which means the business is never asked to switch everything on one frightening weekend.

How I'd Decide if It Were My Business

  1. List every tool and what it costs in a year, counting every seat, because the total is nearly always higher than people expect.
  2. Mark the ones doing a standard job well and leave them alone.
  3. For the rest, count the places where the same information is entered, and note who does the entering.
  4. Ask which tool would hurt most if its price doubled or the vendor withdrew it, since that is the one you depend on without owning.
  5. See it before you commit. Ask for a working prototype of the part you would build, using your own process, so that the decision rests on something you have used.

The last step matters more than the other four. Most owners know their own operation far better than they know what software could do for it, which is exactly as it should be. You know your business, and it is our job to show you the system it needs and then build it, so that you are choosing between things you can see.

BY BANKS designs and builds bespoke business software for companies across the UAE, the GCC and internationally, from a single system for one team to a platform that runs the whole operation. If you are weighing up the same decision, get in touch and we will tell you plainly which of your tools to keep.