I have spent well over a decade checking how retailers present and sell other people's brands on their own websites. It is the work that won me my longest-standing client, a global sportswear brand, and the tools we use for it now read over a million data points a day. The lessons have been remarkably stable across categories and countries, and most of them come back to one uncomfortable fact, which is that a brand's sales are won or lost on pages it does not control.

The Agreement and the Page Are Different Things

A brand and a retailer agree a price, a set of images and copy, a position in the category and a promotion calendar, and everyone leaves the meeting believing that is what shoppers will see. What appears on the site is whatever the retailer's team had time to load, and it goes on changing afterwards without anyone telling the brand. It is rare for an audit to find the live pages matching the agreement in full, and the gap is usually wider than the brand expected.

Nobody Is Doing It on Purpose

It is tempting to read these gaps as bad faith, and that is almost never the cause. A retailer's e-commerce team is looking after thousands of products from hundreds of brands with a handful of people, so an old image, a missing size or a promotion that went live late is nearly always a matter of workload. That affects how you should raise it, because a retailer who feels accused will defend themselves, whereas one who is shown a specific fault with the evidence attached will usually fix it. We have written before about why both sides of the brand and retailer relationship are struggling, and nothing I have seen since has changed my mind.

The Same Six Faults Turn Up Everywhere

FaultWhat the shopper sees
Price driftA price or discount that differs from the one that was agreed
Content decayOld images, thin copy or the wrong product details
Lost visibilityYour products sliding down the category and search results
Stock gapsThe sizes or colours that sell best showing as unavailable
Competitor takeoverA rival holding the banners and top positions that used to be yours
Promotion failuresA campaign that started late, ended early or never appeared

We call the combined effect Trade Dilution™, because each fault looks minor when taken alone, and together they wear away what the brand agreed and paid for.

Evidence Changes the Conversation

The most useful thing an audit produces is a dated record of what a page showed. A brand manager who says that a promotion "did not seem to run properly" gets sympathy, and one who sends the page as it appeared on the launch morning, beside the agreed terms, gets a correction. When a global sportswear brand needed products taken down at set times and never discounted across its retailers, it was that kind of record, gathered from every retailer's site, that kept the launch in line.

It Has to Be Checked Every Day

A weekend promotion is over before a monthly report has been written, and a product that drops off the first page of a category on a Tuesday has lost days of sales by the time anyone notices at the next review. Checking by hand cannot keep up with that, which is why the work only became practical at scale once software could read every retailer's pages daily and flag what had changed. AI has widened it again, to marketplaces and social channels and to comparisons with competitors that nobody had the hours to make.

Audits Find Sales as Well as Faults

Brands commission an audit expecting a list of problems, and the findings they value most are often the openings. A rival out of stock in a category, a search term on a retailer's site that no brand has claimed and a category page where your strongest product is missing are all visible from the outside to anyone reading the pages closely. Passed quickly to the right person, those are sales the brand would otherwise never have known were available.

Software Finds It and People Fix It

Flagging a fault changes nothing until somebody raises it with the retailer and checks that it has been put right. That is the job of our Trade Dilution Analysts, who work inside a brand's trade and e-commerce teams, confirm what the software found, send the evidence to the retailer and go back to verify the fix. The brands that get the most from this work treat it as a routine the two sides share, which keeps it away from blame and makes each conversation easier than the one before.

BY BANKS provides digital retail intelligence for brands that sell through retailers, working from the outside on what shoppers see, so no access to a retailer's systems is needed. If you would like to know what your own retailers are showing today, get in touch and I will show you what we would check first.